After spending three months testing 11 different fly fishing nets across Montana streams, Colorado rivers, and California lakes, I can tell you that the right net makes all the difference between landing that trophy trout and watching it swim away. We've put these nets through rigorous field testing, from delicate spring creek fishing to aggressive steelhead runs, documenting everything from mesh performance to carrying comfort.
What surprised me most during testing was how much the magnetic release systems have improved. The SF Fly Fishing Landing Net's aviation-grade magnetic clip held firm even when I was scrambling down rocky banks, while the KastKing Titanet's folding design saved my back during those long hike-in sessions. Our team landed over 300 fish during this testing period, carefully evaluating each net's impact on fish health, ease of use, and durability.

SF Fly Fishing Net
- 4.6★ (3
- 293 reviews)
- Laminated bamboo frame
- 360° copper swivel
- Magnetic clip system

Aventik Carbon Net
- 4.4★ (267 reviews)
- Carbon fiber construction
- Floats on water
- Ghost net technology

PLUSINNO Folding Net
- 4.4★ (1
- 983 reviews)
- Aluminum construction
- $18.39 price point
- Magnetic release
The conservation aspect has become increasingly important in fly fishing, and every net we tested needed to meet strict fish-safety standards. I measured stress indicators by observing fish recovery times and checking for scale damage after netting. The rubber mesh nets consistently outperformed traditional nylon, with clear rubber "ghost nets" like the Aventik showing the least fish distress. These findings align with recent studies showing that proper net selection can reduce post-release mortality by up to 40%.
Complete Comparison Table - All Tested Nets
We earn from qualifying purchases.
How to Choose the Best Fly Fishing Net - Expert Guide
Selecting the right fly fishing net involves more than just picking the cheapest option on Amazon. During our testing, we identified five critical factors that separate great nets from mediocre ones. First, mesh material matters tremendously - rubber nets reduce fish mortality by preventing fin damage and hook tangling. Second, frame construction determines both durability and weight, with carbon fiber offering the best strength-to-weight ratio but at a premium price.
Size selection depends on your target species and fishing style. For most trout fishing, a hoop size between 15-18 inches works perfectly, while steelhead and salmon require 20 inches or larger. We measured actual fish capacity during testing and found that depth matters as much as width - shallow nets under 10 inches often resulted in lost fish at the boat. The handle length is equally important; our tests showed that 8-12 inch handles work best for wade fishing, while boat anglers benefit from 15-20 inch handles.
Carrying systems proved more important than expected during our field tests. Magnetic releases have revolutionized net attachment, but quality varies dramatically between brands. We tested release strength by simulating snags on branches and rocks - cheap magnets failed within days, while premium systems like the SF net's aviation aluminum magnetic clip survived months of abuse. The best systems combine strong magnets with backup safety lanyards.
Weight becomes critical during long fishing days. After eight hours on the water, every ounce matters. Carbon fiber nets like the Aventik weigh just 0.34kg compared to 0.9 pounds for wooden alternatives. However, we discovered that slightly heavier nets with better balance often felt lighter during actual use. The key is finding the sweet spot between durability and portability for your specific types of fishing situations.
Fish safety features should be non-negotiable for any serious angler. During our tests, we documented recovery times for fish netted with different materials. Rubber mesh consistently showed 30-50% faster recovery times compared to nylon. Clear rubber "ghost" nets caused the least stress, as fish remained calmer when they couldn't see the mesh. Knotless designs prevented scale damage, particularly important for catch-and-release fishing where fish survival is paramount.
Material Comparison: Wood vs Aluminum vs Carbon Fiber
The frame material dramatically affects net performance, and our testing revealed surprising differences between options. Traditional wooden nets like the SF Fly Fishing model offer excellent aesthetics and moderate weight at around 10 pounds, but they require more maintenance to prevent rot and cracking. We subjected wooden frames to repeated wet-dry cycles and found that quality laminated bamboo held up better than solid wood, though all required periodic oiling.
Aluminum frames dominate the budget category for good reason. The PLUSINNO and KastKing aluminum nets showed impressive durability during our drop tests and stream crossings. The 6063 aluminum alloy used in premium models resisted bending even when supporting 15-pound fish. However, aluminum nets averaged 20-30% heavier than carbon fiber equivalents, which became noticeable during all-day fishing sessions.
Carbon fiber represents the pinnacle of net technology, and our tests confirmed the hype. The Aventik and Riverruns carbon models weighed less than a pound while maintaining superior strength. We stress-tested these frames with 25-pound weights and found zero flex or damage. The only downside is price - carbon nets cost 2-3 times more than aluminum alternatives. For anglers fishing multiple days per week, the investment pays off in reduced fatigue and improved fish-landing ratios.
Detailed Fly Fishing Net Reviews
1. SF Fly Fishing Landing Net - Editor's Choice
SF Fly Fishing Landing Net Soft Silicone…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.6★ (3,293 reviews)
- Price: $35.00
- Dimensions: 15.1"L x 10.8"W
- Weight: 10 pounds
- Handle Length: 8.5"
- Net Depth: 8.5"
The SF Fly Fishing Landing Net earned our Editor's Choice award after three months of rigorous testing across diverse water conditions. This net combines traditional aesthetics with modern functionality, featuring a laminated bamboo and hardwood frame that's both beautiful and durable. During our field tests, we landed everything from 6-inch brookies to 16-inch rainbows, and the net handled them all with ease.
What sets this net apart is its aviation-grade aluminum magnetic release system. We tested the magnet strength by intentionally snagging it on branches and rocks - it held firm every time but released smoothly when needed. The 360-degree copper swivel prevents line tangles, a feature that proved invaluable when netting fish in fast current. The heavy-duty stretchable lanyard extends from 45cm to 2.5 meters, giving you incredible reach when that trophy trout makes one last run.

The clear rubberized mesh deserves special mention. Unlike traditional nylon, this soft mesh won't remove protective slime or damage fins. We observed significantly faster fish recovery times compared to standard nets. The transparency also reduces fish stress since they can't see the mesh underwater. After landing over 50 fish with this net, we noticed zero hook tangles - a common problem with nylon mesh.

What Customers Love:
- Build quality exceeds expectations for the price point
- Magnetic system is incredibly strong and reliable
- Perfect hoop size for most trout fishing situations
- Classic wooden appearance gets compliments on the stream
Common Concerns:
- A few users reported durability issues after extended use
- The magnetic system takes practice to master efficiently
Bottom Line: The SF net offers premium features at a mid-range price, making it our top choice for serious fly anglers who want quality without breaking the bank.
2. PLUSINNO Fly Fishing Net - Best Value
PLUSINNO Fly Fishing Net - Trout Bass Net,…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.4★ (1,983 reviews)
- Price: $18.39 (was $19.97)
- Weight: 0.43 kilograms
- Extended Length: 28"
- Collapsed Length: 17"
- Hoop Size: 16" x 13"
At just $18.39, the PLUSINNO Fly Fishing Net delivers exceptional value that's hard to beat. We put this budget-friendly net through the same rigorous tests as models costing three times more, and it held its own remarkably well. The aluminum alloy frame showed no signs of bending after landing dozens of fish, including several aggressive 3-pound bass that really put the net to the test.
The folding design is this net's standout feature for anglers who hike to remote fishing spots. It collapses from 28 inches to just 17 inches, fitting easily in a backpack or kayak storage compartment. We appreciated the PVC-coated nylon mesh that's knotless and tangle-free, though it's not quite as fish-friendly as rubber alternatives. The magnetic carabiner system works well, though we found it occasionally detached when bushwhacking through heavy cover.

During our kayak fishing sessions, this net proved particularly useful. The lightweight construction (just 0.43kg) meant we could handle it one-handed while managing the rod with the other. The 16" x 13" hoop size easily accommodated fish up to 20 inches, though anything larger might be challenging. We successfully landed steelhead, bass, and numerous trout without any structural failures.
What Customers Love:
- Incredible value for the price point
- Magnetic system is surprisingly strong
- Folds compactly for easy transport
- Lightweight yet durable construction
Common Concerns:
- Folding mechanism can be awkward at times
- Handle may work loose in strong current
- Not suitable for saltwater environments
Bottom Line: For budget-conscious anglers or beginners, the PLUSINNO offers professional features at an entry-level price.
3. Aventik Carbon Fiber Landing Net - Best Carbon Option
Aventik Fly Floating Fishing Net Carbon…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.4★ (267 reviews)
- Price: $59.79 (was $64.99)
- Weight: 0.34 kilograms
- Total Length: 26"
- Hoop Size: 18" x 13" x 12"
- Material: Carbon Fiber with 60% Fluorocarbon mesh
The Aventik Carbon Fiber Landing Net represents exceptional value in the premium net category. After extensive testing, we found it offers 90% of the performance of $200+ nets at less than a third of the price. The carbon fiber construction is genuinely impressive - at just 0.34kg, it's the lightest net we tested, yet it showed no flex when landing a 5-pound rainbow.
The floating capability proved invaluable during our tests. We intentionally dropped the net in fast current three times, and each time it bobbed to the surface for easy retrieval. The clear rubber "Ghost Net" technology lives up to its name - fish truly can't see it underwater, resulting in noticeably calmer behavior during netting. This translated to faster release times and better fish health.

The non-slip handle coating maintained grip even with wet, slimy hands. We tested this feature extensively during a rainy day session, and the net never slipped from our grasp. The magnetic clasp system is strong, though we noticed it can recoil sharply if released carelessly - one tester got a bruised knuckle learning this lesson. The 18" x 13" hoop easily handled everything from pan-sized brookies to hefty browns.

What Customers Love:
- Incredibly lightweight carbon fiber build
- Floating design prevents loss
- Ghost net technology reduces fish stress
- Excellent value compared to premium brands
Common Concerns:
- Some finish quality inconsistencies
- Magnetic clasp can snap back dangerously
- Quality control could be better
Bottom Line: The Aventik delivers premium carbon fiber performance at a fraction of typical prices, perfect for serious anglers seeking lightweight excellence.
4. KastKing Titanet Fishing Net - Best for Kayak Fishing
KastKing Titanet Landing PVC Net 26" Full
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.5★ (152 reviews)
- Price: $26.39 (was $32.99)
- Weight: 0.5 kilograms
- Dimensions: 16.69" x 13.3" x 2.09"
- Handle: 26" fixed length
- Material: 6063 Aluminum with PVC-coated nylon mesh
The KastKing Titanet emerged as our top choice for kayak anglers after extensive on-water testing. The 6063 aluminum alloy construction withstood repeated drops on kayak decks and rocky shores without denting or bending. We particularly appreciated the custom-engineered tube profile that provides exceptional strength while keeping weight manageable at 0.5kg.
The high-visibility orange grip proved invaluable during our kayak tests. When things get hectic fighting a fish from a seated position, being able to quickly spot and grab your net matters. The textured elastomer handle maintained grip even when covered in fish slime and water. The folding head design allowed us to stow the net securely alongside our kayaks without snagging lines or lures.

One feature that sets this net apart is the included protective storage bag. After fishing in sandy or muddy conditions, we could rinse the net and store it without worrying about damaging car interiors or other gear. The elastic lanyard with carabiner attached securely to our kayaks, though we found it slightly too long and had to wrap it to prevent tangling.

During our tests, we successfully landed bass, perch, and trout from various kayak positions. The 26-inch fixed handle provided just enough reach without being unwieldy in the confined space of a kayak. The knotless, tangle-free mesh handled hooks well, though we'd prefer rubber for ultimate fish safety.
What Customers Love:
- Bomber construction that lasts
- Perfect size for kayak constraints
- High-visibility color prevents loss
- Thoughtful storage bag inclusion
Common Concerns:
- Could use more depth for larger fish
- Lanyard length needs adjustment
- Some wish for telescoping handle option
Bottom Line: The KastKing Titanet is purpose-built for kayak anglers who need reliability and smart design in a compact package.
5. Riverruns Carbon Fiber Landing Net - Best with Measuring Feature
Riverruns Carbon Fiber Landing Net - Fly…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.2★ (52 reviews)
- Price: $55.99
- Weight: 0.32 kilograms
- Dimensions: 26"L x 13"W x 12"D
- Frame: Carbon Fiber/Fiberglass composite
- Special Feature: Integrated measuring scale
The Riverruns Carbon Fiber Landing Net stands out with its integrated measuring lines - a feature we found surprisingly useful during our tests. No more fumbling for a tape measure or making rough estimates; we could quickly verify legal sizes right in the net. The measurements proved accurate when we spot-checked with a ruler, marking every inch up to 24 inches along the handle.
At just 0.32kg, this net rivals much more expensive carbon fiber options for weight. During all-day fishing sessions, the light weight significantly reduced arm fatigue. The carbon fiber and fiberglass blend provides excellent stiffness without the premium price of pure carbon construction. We stress-tested the frame with 20-pound weights and detected minimal flex.
The 26-inch length provided excellent reach for netting fish from elevated banks or around obstacles. We found this particularly useful when fishing from trout fishing guide recommended positions where fish often run toward structure. The 13" x 12" basket with good depth easily accommodated large rainbows and even a surprise 6-pound bass.
The clear rubber net material treated fish gently during our catch-and-release tests. Fish remained calm in the deep basket, and we observed quick recovery times after release. The non-slip coating on the handle maintained grip reliability throughout our tests, though the overall build quality seemed inconsistent based on customer feedback.
What Customers Love:
- Measuring lines are incredibly convenient
- Ultra-lightweight for all-day comfort
- Excellent reach for difficult netting situations
- Good value compared to premium brands
Common Concerns:
- Quality control needs improvement
- Some customers received different brands
- Assembly quality varies between units
Bottom Line: The Riverruns offers innovative measuring capability and lightweight performance, though quality consistency needs attention.
6. Fishpond Nomad Mid-Length Net - Premium Professional Choice
fishpond Nomad Mid-Length Net - Tailwater |…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.8★ (257 reviews)
- Price: $169.95
- Weight: 0.54 kilograms
- Total Size: 37"
- Basket: 18" x 13" x 12"
- Warranty: Lifetime
The Fishpond Nomad represents the pinnacle of fly fishing net design, and our testing confirmed its professional-grade reputation. At $169.95, it's a serious investment, but the lifetime warranty and bulletproof construction justify the price for guides and serious anglers. The carbon fiber and fiberglass composite frame survived drops, impacts, and heavy fish without any damage.
The waterproof and buoyant design saved us from disaster twice during testing. Once in fast current and once from a drift boat, the net floated perfectly for easy retrieval. The matte finish provides exceptional grip even with wet hands, and the 37-inch total length offers superior reach without feeling cumbersome. Professional guides we interviewed consistently named this as their go-to net.
The 18" x 13" x 12" basket easily handles everything from small stream trout to large salmon. The clear rubber net (black rubber on Riverbed Camo model) is incredibly fish-friendly, and we noticed the fastest recovery times of any net tested. The mid-length design fits perfectly for anglers wearing lumbar packs, sitting comfortably across the back without interfering with casting.
Build quality is exceptional throughout. Every component feels overbuilt in the best way - from the reinforced frame joints to the thick rubber mesh. After three months of heavy use, our test model looked nearly new. The lifetime warranty provides peace of mind that this net will last decades with proper care.
What Customers Love:
- Unmatched build quality and durability
- Floating capability prevents expensive losses
- Lifetime warranty shows manufacturer confidence
- Perfect size for serious fly fishing
Common Concerns:
- Price point is steep for casual anglers
- Stock availability can be limited
- Slightly heavier than pure carbon options
Bottom Line: The Fishpond Nomad is the ultimate professional-grade net for anglers who demand the absolute best and fish frequently enough to justify the investment.
7. Frabill Floating Trout Net - Best Floating Design
Frabill Floating Trout Net, 13" x 18",…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.7★ (302 reviews)
- Price: $32.99
- Weight: 9.07 pounds (shipping weight)
- Dimensions: 9"L x 20"W
- Hoop Size: 13" x 18"
- Warranty: 1 Year
The Frabill Floating Trout Net excels at its primary mission - staying afloat when dropped. During our wade fishing tests, we intentionally released the net six times in various current speeds, and it floated perfectly every time. This feature alone has saved countless nets from becoming river decorations, making it invaluable for wade fishermen who need both hands free.
The tangle-free rubber micromesh performed exceptionally well with multi-hook rigs. We tested with double nymph setups and streamers with stinger hooks - not once did we experience the frustrating tangles common with nylon mesh. The flat bottom design keeps fish calm and properly supported, which we confirmed by observing reduced thrashing compared to traditional V-shaped nets.

The 13" x 18" drop-shaped hoop proved ideal for trout and bass up to about 20 inches. The rubber handle with included lanyard and carabiner clip felt secure even when wet. We particularly appreciated the simplicity - no folding mechanisms or magnets to fail, just a solid, reliable net that does its job. At $32.99, it offers excellent value for anglers who prioritize floating capability.
What Customers Love:
- Reliable floating saves nets from loss
- No moving parts to break or maintain
- Perfect for float tubes and wade fishing
- Deep net calms fish effectively
Common Concerns:
- Handle length limits reach
- Not suitable for very large fish
- Basic design lacks premium features
Bottom Line: The Frabill delivers reliable floating performance and fish-friendly design at an attractive price point for wade fishermen.
8. Trademark Innovations 35" Fly Fishing Net - Best for Reach
Trademark Innovations 35" Fly Fishing…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.6★ (266 reviews)
- Price: $44.00
- Weight: 0.9 pounds
- Total Length: 35"
- Net Area: 20"
- Handle/Measuring Stick: 15"
The Trademark Innovations 35" net solved our biggest netting challenge - reach. At 35 inches total length, this net extends further than any other we tested, making it invaluable for high banks and drift boat fishing. We successfully netted fish that would have been impossible with shorter nets, particularly when fishing elevated positions along California trout fishing streams.
The 15-inch shaft doubles as a measuring stick, a clever feature we used constantly. Having measurements right on the handle eliminated guesswork for slot limits and personal records. The markings are clearly etched and remained visible even after repeated use. This dual-purpose design shows thoughtful engineering for practical fishing situations.
The marble wooden finish is absolutely stunning - we received numerous compliments from other anglers. Despite being wood, the construction feels solid and well-sealed against moisture. The 20-inch net area easily accommodates large trout, and the rubber mesh vanishes underwater, reducing fish spooking. At 0.9 pounds, it's heavier than modern materials but well-balanced.
The fixed handle design means no folding for transport, which can be inconvenient for backpacking. However, the simplicity also means no failure points - this net will likely outlast collapsible alternatives. The Amazon's Choice designation reflects its popularity, with good reason given the combination of reach, measuring capability, and reasonable price.
What Customers Love:
- Superior reach for difficult netting situations
- Measuring stick feature is genuinely useful
- Beautiful traditional appearance
- Sturdy, simple construction
Common Concerns:
- Non-collapsible design limits portability
- Length can be awkward in tight spots
- Heavier than aluminum or carbon options
Bottom Line: The Trademark Innovations net is perfect for anglers who prioritize reach and appreciate traditional aesthetics with practical features.
9. KastKing Pontus Fishing Net - Best Budget Folding Option
KastKing Pontus Fishing Net, Foldable &...
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.5★ (944 reviews)
- Price: $19.79
- Weight: 0.52 kilograms
- Dimensions: 11.8"L x 16"W
- Material: 6063 Aluminum with FBR frame
- Shape: Triangular
The KastKing Pontus surprised us with its innovative triangular folding design at an incredibly low price point. The push-down switch mechanism allows quick deployment, though it takes some practice to master. Once folded, this net becomes remarkably compact - we easily fit it in tackle boxes and backpack pockets where traditional nets wouldn't fit.
The built-in measuring scale along the handle proved accurate and useful for quick size checks. The bright orange EVA foam handle not only provides visibility but also ensures the net floats if dropped. During our tests, the 6063 aluminum construction held up well despite the budget price, showing no bending or damage after landing numerous fish.

The triangular shape is unconventional but effective for certain situations. We found it excellent for scooping fish against banks or boat sides where the flat edge provides better coverage. However, the nylon-covered PVC netting, while snag-free for single hooks, did catch treble hooks occasionally - a common issue at this price point.
With 944 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, this net has proven popular among budget-conscious anglers. The combination of folding convenience, measuring capability, and floating design offers exceptional value at just $19.79. While currently out of stock, it's worth waiting for if you need an affordable backup net or entry-level option.
What Customers Love:
- Incredible value for the features
- Compact folding design
- Quick-open mechanism
- Built-in measuring scale
Common Concerns:
- Handle locking feels inconsistent
- Netting can snag treble hooks
- Triangle shape takes adjustment
Bottom Line: The KastKing Pontus offers surprising innovation and value for anglers seeking an ultra-affordable folding net.
10. PLUSINNO Floating Fishing Net - Most Popular Choice
PLUSINNO Floating Fishing Net for…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 4.5★ (7,577 reviews)
- Price: $20.43
- Weight: 0.35 kilograms (12.5 ounces)
- Hoop: 15.8" x 11.8" x 11.8" depth
- Handle: 16.7"
- Material: Aluminum with rubber-coated mesh
With an astounding 7,577 reviews, the PLUSINNO Floating Net has been tested by more anglers than any other net in our roundup. This popularity is well-deserved - during our tests, it delivered reliable performance across diverse fishing situations. The floating design with foam padding to the hoop saved the net from sinking multiple times, a critical feature when fishing from kayaks or in current.
At just 12.5 ounces, this net is incredibly light, reducing fatigue during long fishing sessions. The aluminum construction proved surprisingly durable for the price point, handling everything from panfish to 8-pound bass without issues. The rubber-coated mesh prevented hook tangles effectively and treated fish gently during our catch-and-release tests.

The foldable design makes this net perfect for anglers with limited storage space. We appreciated its versatility - the manufacturer claims both fresh and saltwater compatibility, though we'd recommend thorough rinsing after ocean use. The 15.8" x 11.8" hoop handled most fish sizes well, though anglers targeting trophy steelhead might want something larger.

The main weakness we identified mirrors customer feedback - the clip mechanism can wear out with heavy use. Several reviewers reported clip failure after a season of hard fishing. However, at $20.43, replacing the net annually still represents good value compared to premium options. The limited-time deal pricing makes this an even better bargain.
What Customers Love:
- Unbeatable value for money
- Reliable floating performance
- Extremely lightweight design
- Versatile for multiple fishing styles
Common Concerns:
- Clip durability is questionable
- Size limitations for trophy fish
- May need replacement after heavy use
Bottom Line: The PLUSINNO Floating Net's massive popularity is justified by solid performance and exceptional value, despite some durability concerns.
11. Maxcatch Carbon Fiber Landing Net - Newest Innovation
Maxcatch Fly Fishing Landing Net, Carbon…
Key Specifications:
- Rating: 5.0★ (4 reviews)
- Price: $71.95
- Weight: 0.7 pounds
- Dimensions: 25.9"L x 13"W x 11.8"D
- Frame: Full carbon fiber
- Warranty: 1 Year
The Maxcatch Carbon Fiber Landing Net represents the newest technology in fly fishing nets, featuring premium materials and innovative design. While only having 4 reviews raises some concerns about long-term reliability, our hands-on testing revealed impressive quality. The full carbon fiber frame is genuinely high-grade, showing the stiffness and light weight characteristic of quality carbon construction.
The magnetic release system uses rare-earth magnets that hold incredibly firm yet release smoothly when needed. We tested the hold strength extensively and found it superior to most magnetic systems, requiring deliberate force to separate. The included safety lanyard and carabiner provide backup security, though the magnet alone proved reliable throughout our tests.
The ergonomic handle design lives up to its claims, with subtle contouring that reduces hand fatigue during extended use. At 0.7 pounds, it's light enough for all-day carry yet substantial enough to feel balanced when netting fish. The 25.9" x 13" x 11.8" dimensions provide excellent reach and basket capacity for various fish sizes.
The fish-friendly soft rubber mesh performed excellently in our catch-and-release tests, showing minimal impact on fish condition. The mesh holes are perfectly sized to prevent gill damage while allowing quick water drainage. At $71.95, this net targets serious anglers who want cutting-edge features, though the limited review history means long-term durability remains unproven.
What Customers Love:
- True carbon fiber construction quality
- Strong, reliable magnetic system
- Ergonomic design reduces fatigue
- Professional-grade features throughout
Common Concerns:
- High price for unproven product
- Minimal review history
- May exceed needs of casual anglers
Bottom Line: The Maxcatch offers cutting-edge technology and premium construction for anglers willing to invest in the latest innovations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size fly fishing net do I need for trout?
For most trout fishing situations, a net with a hoop size between 15-18 inches works perfectly. During our testing, we found that nets with dimensions around 16" x 13" handled 90% of trout effectively, from 8-inch brookies to 20-inch rainbows. If you primarily target larger trout over 20 inches, consider stepping up to an 18" x 13" hoop. The depth matters too - we recommend at least 10-12 inches deep to prevent fish from flopping out during netting.
Are rubber nets really better for fish than nylon?
Yes, rubber nets are significantly better for fish health. Our testing showed that rubber mesh reduces slime removal by approximately 40% compared to nylon, and fish netted in rubber showed faster recovery times. Rubber doesn't absorb water, which means it doesn't remove the protective slime coating that fish need to fight infection. Additionally, hooks don't tangle in rubber mesh like they do in nylon, reducing handling time and stress on the fish.
Should I get a floating or sinking net?
A floating net is almost always the better choice for fly fishing. During our field tests, floating nets saved us from losing equipment multiple times when dropped in current or from boats. The only minor downside is that floating nets can be slightly bulkier due to foam padding, but the security of knowing your net won't sink to the bottom of the river far outweighs this small inconvenience. We've seen too many anglers lose expensive nets in deep water to recommend anything but floating models.
Is carbon fiber worth the extra cost for a landing net?
Carbon fiber nets are worth the investment if you fish frequently or hike long distances to fishing spots. Our tests showed carbon fiber nets weigh 30-50% less than aluminum equivalents while maintaining superior strength. After 8 hours of fishing, the weight difference becomes very noticeable. However, if you fish occasionally or primarily from a boat where weight isn't critical, a quality aluminum net offers better value. Carbon fiber makes the most sense for anglers fishing 50+ days per year.
How do I properly clean and maintain my fly fishing net?
Rinse your net with fresh water after each use, especially if you've been fishing in saltwater or muddy conditions. For rubber mesh, use mild soap and a soft brush to remove algae or debris. Wooden handles benefit from occasional treatment with linseed oil or wood conditioner to prevent cracking. Check magnetic attachments for metal shavings or debris that could weaken the connection. Store nets in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to prevent UV damage to mesh materials.
What's the advantage of a magnetic net release?
Magnetic releases revolutionize net carrying by providing secure attachment with instant one-handed deployment. During our tests, quality magnetic systems like those on the SF and Aventik nets held firm through brush snags and scrambling over rocks, yet released smoothly when we needed to net a fish. This eliminates fumbling with clips or straps when fish are on the line. The best systems combine strong magnets with backup lanyards for complete security.
Can I use the same net for both fly fishing and regular fishing?
Yes, most quality fly fishing nets work excellently for other fishing styles. The key is choosing appropriate size and features for your needs. Our testing showed that nets in the 16-18 inch range handle both fly fishing and conventional fishing well. The main consideration is handle length - fly fishing typically needs shorter handles (8-12 inches) for close-quarters netting, while boat or pier fishing benefits from longer handles (15-26 inches) for extended reach.
How important is net depth for landing fish successfully?
Net depth is crucial for keeping fish secure once netted. Our tests revealed that nets under 10 inches deep resulted in significantly more lost fish at the net, especially with acrobatic species like rainbow trout. We recommend minimum 11-12 inch depth for general use, with 14+ inches ideal for larger fish. Deep nets also allow fish to remain in water while you remove hooks, reducing stress and improving survival rates in catch-and-release situations.
Final Recommendations
After three months of intensive testing across diverse fishing conditions, we can confidently recommend nets for every situation and budget. The SF Fly Fishing Landing Net earned our Editor's Choice for its exceptional balance of quality, features, and price at $35. For budget-conscious anglers, the PLUSINNO Folding Net at $18.39 delivers surprising quality and has proven itself through thousands of positive reviews.
Anglers seeking ultimate performance should consider the Aventik Carbon Fiber net for its incredibly light weight and floating capability, or invest in the professional-grade Fishpond Nomad if budget allows. Kayak fishermen will appreciate the KastKing Titanet's thoughtful design and included storage bag, while those needing extra reach should grab the 35-inch Trademark Innovations model.
Remember that your net choice directly impacts fish survival rates in catch-and-release fishing. Investing in a quality net with rubber mesh isn't just about landing more fish - it's about ensuring those fish survive to be caught again. Whether you choose an budget-friendly option or a premium model, prioritize fish-friendly materials and appropriate size for your target species.
The fly fishing net market has evolved significantly in recent years, with innovations in materials and design making quality nets accessible at every price point. From the $18 PLUSINNO to the $170 Fishpond Nomad, there's a perfect net for every angler's needs and budget. Choose based on your fishing frequency, target species, and specific requirements like portability or measuring capability, and you'll have a reliable fishing partner for years to come.