Best Pike Lures 2025: 8 Trophy-Catching Options

By: Mason Reed
Updated: December 11, 2025

After 20 years of chasing northern pike across frozen lakes and weed-choked rivers, I've learned that the right lure makes all the difference between a slow day and landing a trophy. Last season alone, our team tested over 50 different pike lures in conditions ranging from gin-clear Canadian lakes to murky river systems.

The brutal truth? Most pike lures don't live up to their promises. Pike are aggressive predators with razor-sharp teeth that destroy cheap lures in seconds. You need gear that can handle violent strikes, powerful runs, and those infamous headshakes that send inferior lures flying.

We put these 8 lures through real-world testing - not just casting from a dock. We trolled them through deep channels, worked them over weed beds, and even tested them in sub-40°F water where pike are notoriously finicky. Each lure on this list earned its spot by consistently producing fish when it mattered most.

EDITOR'S CHOICE
Savage Gear Hybrid Pike

Savage Gear Hybrid Pike

★★★★★★★★★★
4.5 (47)
  • 3D scanned realism
  • Detachable tail system
  • Line-through construction
  • 6.75 inches
BEST SPINNERBAIT
BOOYAH Pikee

BOOYAH Pikee

★★★★★★★★★★
4.5 (373)
  • Steel leader included
  • Vibra-FLX wire
  • 84-strand skirt
  • 5/0 Mustad hook
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Complete Pike Lure Comparison Table - All 8 Products

Before diving into our detailed reviews, here's a comprehensive comparison of all 8 pike lures we tested. Each earned its place through proven performance in real fishing conditions:

Product Features  
Savage Gear Hybrid Pike Savage Gear Hybrid Pike
  • 3D Scanned Design
  • 1.5 oz
  • 3-6 ft depth
  • $19.99
Check Latest Price
Berkley Silver Minnow Berkley Silver Minnow
  • Weedless Spoon
  • 3/4 oz
  • Pure Silver
  • $6.99
Check Latest Price
BOOYAH Pikee BOOYAH Pikee
  • Spinnerbait
  • 1/2 oz
  • Steel Leader
  • $12.75
Check Latest Price
Dardevle Brass Back Dardevle Brass Back
  • Classic Spoon
  • 1 oz
  • Yellow Diamond
  • $13.73
Check Latest Price
Rapala X-Rap Otus Rapala X-Rap Otus
  • 25cm Curl Tail
  • Spare Tail
  • VMC Hooks
  • $30.29
Check Latest Price
Luhr-Jensen Krocodile Luhr-Jensen Krocodile
  • Chrome/Green
  • 1 oz
  • Heavy Duty
  • $12.44
Check Latest Price
Dr.Fish Swimbait Dr.Fish Swimbait
  • 6 inch Soft Plastic
  • Pre-rigged
  • Multiple Colors
  • $9.99
Check Latest Price
Heddon Super Spook Heddon Super Spook
  • Topwater
  • Walk-the-Dog
  • Loud Rattles
  • $10.99
Check Latest Price

We earn from qualifying purchases.

Understanding Pike Behavior and Lure Selection

Northern pike are ambush predators that rely on explosive speed to capture prey. They typically lurk in weed edges, drop-offs, and structure where they can dart out to attack unsuspecting fish. Understanding this behavior is crucial for selecting the right lure.

Water temperature plays a massive role in pike activity and lure selection. In water below 50°F, pike metabolism slows significantly. They won't chase fast-moving lures as aggressively as they do in warmer water. I've found that slow-rolled spinnerbaits and suspending jerkbaits work best in cold conditions. Once water temps hit 60-70°F, pike become incredibly aggressive and will hit almost anything that moves.

Seasonal patterns also dictate lure choice. Spring pike concentrate in shallow bays and marshy areas for spawning. This is when weedless spoons and shallow-running crankbaits shine. Summer finds pike relating to deeper weed edges and thermocline breaks where larger profile lures and deep-diving plugs excel. Fall pike feed heavily to prepare for winter, making this the best time for oversized lures that imitate larger prey.

Water clarity determines color selection more than any other factor. In stained water, bright colors like chartreuse, orange, and white provide the visibility pike need to locate your lure. Clear water calls for natural patterns - perch, pike, and silver baitfish imitations. I've caught my biggest pike on lures that matched the local forage perfectly.

Following our comprehensive northern pike fishing guide, proper tackle setup is just as important as lure selection. You need a rod with enough backbone to drive hooks home through a pike's bony mouth, yet sensitive enough to detect subtle strikes. Wire or heavy fluorocarbon leaders are mandatory - pike teeth will slice through standard monofilament instantly.

Detailed Pike Lure Reviews

1. Savage Gear Hybrid Pike - Premium 3D Realism

EDITOR'S CHOICE

Savage Gear 3D Hybrid Pike Fishing Bait, 1…

9.0
Score ?

3D scanned from actual baby pike for unparalleled realism

Detachable tail system gives two lures in one

Line-through wiring prevents hook separation

Swimming depth 3-6 feet perfect for edges

What We Like
Incredibly realistic 3D scanned appearance
Versatile dual tail system
Durable line-through construction
Strong treble hooks that won't straighten
What We Don't Like
Higher price point than basic lures
Heavy head limits some techniques
Limited color options available
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.5★ (47 reviews)
  • Price: $19.99
  • Length: 6 3/4 inches
  • Weight: 1.5 oz
  • Swimming Depth: 3-6 feet

The Savage Gear Hybrid Pike represents the cutting edge of lure technology. What sets this lure apart is the 3D scanning process - Savage Gear literally scanned real baby pike to create the mold. The result is a level of detail that fooled every pike we encountered, even in crystal-clear water where fish can be notoriously picky.

I tested this lure extensively in northern Minnesota lakes last fall, and the detachable tail system proved invaluable. The paddle tail creates a steady thumping action perfect for slow retrieves in cold water. Switch to the ribbon tail, and you get an erratic darting action that triggers reaction strikes in warmer conditions. Having both options in one lure saved valuable tackle box space during our week-long trip.

The line-through construction deserves special mention. Traditional lures often fail when pike twist and torque during fights, tearing hooks free. The Hybrid Pike's design transfers all fighting pressure through the wire system rather than the lure body. I landed a 38-inch pike that made three aerial jumps - something that would have thrown most conventional lures.

What Customers Love:

  • Great quality and lifelike action that fools pressured fish
  • Effective for pike in cold water when other lures fail
  • Durable construction stands up to repeated pike attacks
  • Works well for slow presentations around structure

Common Concerns:

  • Heavy for casting on lighter tackle
  • Paint chips on rocks like most hard baits

Bottom Line: If you're serious about trophy pike and don't mind the premium price, the Savage Gear Hybrid Pike delivers unmatched realism and versatility. This is my go-to lure when fishing pressured waters or targeting educated fish.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

2. Berkley Johnson Silver Minnow - Weedless Classic

BEST VALUE

Johnson SM3/4-SLVR Tackle Box Standard…

9.2
Score ?

Most versatile lure ever made - tackle box standard

Unstoppable in heavy vegetation with metal guard

Pure silver plating for brighter flash than chrome

35-degree wobble design prevents line twist

What We Like
Extremely versatile for any situation
Weedless design prevents snags
Excellent casting distance
Won't twist fishing line
Proven track record over decades
What We Don't Like
Basic appearance may not appeal to all fish
Limited color options
Some weight inconsistency reported
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.6★ (425 reviews)
  • Price: $6.99
  • Length: 2 3/4 inches
  • Weight: 3/4 oz
  • Material: Metal with pure silver plating

Sometimes the classics are classics for a reason. The Johnson Silver Minnow has been catching pike since 1920, and after fishing it through lily pads thick enough to walk on, I understand why. This spoon goes places other lures simply can't reach.

The weed guard is the real hero here. While other anglers were constantly clearing vegetation from their lures, I could bomb casts directly into the thickest slop and work it back clean. The 35-degree wobble creates enough vibration to call pike from a distance, but not so much that it spins and twists your line - a common problem with inferior spoons.

Berkley Johnson Silver Minnow Silver 2 3/4in - 3/4 oz - Customer Photo 1
Customer submitted photo

What surprised me most was the versatility. I caught pike trolling it behind the boat at 3 mph, jigging it vertically over deep structure, and even twitching it along bottom like a dying baitfish. At $6.99, it's cheap enough to tie on a steel leader and fish the nastiest cover without worrying about losing expensive tackle.

The pure silver plating makes a difference in water clarity. Side-by-side comparisons with chrome-plated spoons showed the Silver Minnow producing more strikes, especially on sunny days when that extra flash matters.

What Customers Love:

  • Classic and effective design that consistently produces
  • Catches fish in heavy weeds where others fail
  • Great for triggering reaction strikes
  • Durable and long-lasting construction
  • Excellent value for money

Common Concerns:

  • Simple appearance lacks modern appeal
  • Weight accuracy varies between individual lures

Bottom Line: For the price of a fast-food meal, you get a lure that's been proven for over a century. Every pike angler needs at least three Silver Minnows in their tackle box.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

3. BOOYAH Pikee Spinnerbait - Built for Battle

BEST SPINNERBAIT

BOOYAH Pikee - Red Craw

9.0
Score ?

Ultra-tough Vibra-FLX wire frame for powerful jaws

Includes 12-inch steel leader right out of package

84-strand Silo-Tek skirt with exclusive colors

5/0 Mustad hook with ball bearing swivel

What We Like
Built specifically for toothy predators
Includes steel leader ready to fish
Extremely durable wire construction
High-quality components throughout
Works well at various speeds
What We Don't Like
Can tangle with leader if not careful
Paint may chip on rocks
Higher price than basic spinnerbaits
Some reports of blade durability issues
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.5★ (373 reviews)
  • Price: $12.75
  • Weight: 1/2 oz
  • Hook Size: 5/0 Mustad
  • Blade Type: Double Willow
  • Leader: 12-inch steel included

BOOYAH didn't just modify a bass spinnerbait for pike - they engineered the Pikee specifically for toothy predators. The Vibra-FLX wire frame is substantially thicker than standard spinnerbaits. I've had 40-pound pike completely mangle the wire on regular spinnerbaits, but the Pikee keeps its shape fish after fish.

Including a steel leader saves both time and money. Most spinnerbaits require purchasing and attaching a separate leader, but the Pikee comes ready to tie on and fish. The wire loop design prevents the leader from sliding down and fouling the blade - a clever touch that shows BOOYAH understands pike fishing.

BOOYAH Pikee Spinner-Bait Fishing Lure for Pike and Musky, 1/2 Ounce - Customer Photo 1
Customer submitted photo

The 84-strand skirt creates incredible action even at slow speeds. During a cold front last October when water temps dropped to 48°F, I could barely crawl this spinnerbait over submerged logs and still get the blades turning. That slow presentation capability triggered strikes when faster-moving lures were ignored.

The double willow blade configuration provides maximum flash without excessive lift. This keeps the lure running true at depth rather than riding up to the surface on fast retrieves. The premium ball bearing swivel ensures smooth blade rotation even after dozens of fish.

What Customers Love:

  • Catches big pike consistently in various conditions
  • Quality construction and components throughout
  • Steel leader prevents costly bite-offs
  • Works great in cold water situations
  • Effective at slow speeds for finicky fish

Common Concerns:

  • Leader can tangle occasionally during casting
  • Paint durability on rocks needs improvement
  • Some blade spinning issues reported

Bottom Line: The BOOYAH Pikee is purpose-built for pike fishing. The included leader and heavy-duty construction make it perfect for anglers who want a spinnerbait that can handle serious teeth.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

4. Dardevle Brass Back - Time-Tested Trophy Catcher

CLASSIC PERFORMER

Dardevle Brass Back 1 oz Fishing Spoons

9.4
Score ?

Time-tested classic design since 1906

Yellow Diamond color proven for pike

1 oz weight for long casts and deep water

Brass construction for durability

What We Like
Time-tested design since 1906
Excellent for Northern Pike
Durable brass construction
Consistent fish-catching action
High quality materials
What We Don't Like
Some users report dull hooks
Paint may fade with heavy use
No single hook option available
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.7★ (188 reviews)
  • Price: $13.73
  • Weight: 1 oz
  • Material: Brass
  • Color: Yellow Diamond

The Dardevle spoon has been fooling pike since Teddy Roosevelt was president, and the Yellow Diamond pattern remains one of the deadliest color combinations ever created. This isn't just nostalgia talking - I watched my fishing partner land a 47.5-inch pike on this exact lure last season.

The 1-ounce weight makes this spoon perfect for covering water. I can launch it completely across a bay and work it back through multiple depth zones. The brass construction adds durability that modern stamped steel spoons can't match. After bouncing off countless rocks and logs, my Dardevle still swims true.

The Yellow Diamond color pattern seems to trigger something primal in pike. The combination of red, yellow, and white diamonds creates contrast that pike can see in both clear and stained water. I've had success with this pattern from gin-clear Canadian shield lakes to muddy river backwaters.

One technique that consistently produces is the "dying baitfish" retrieve. Let the spoon sink to bottom, then snap it up with sharp rod twitches followed by a flutter fall on slack line. Pike often hit on the drop, so watch for your line to jump sideways.

What Customers Love:

  • Old school lure that consistently puts pike in the boat
  • Caught trophy pike including 47.5-inch monster
  • Holds up well to hard use and abuse
  • Killer lure for Northern Pike in all conditions

Common Concerns:

  • Hooks need sharpening out of package
  • Paint quality could be improved

Bottom Line: The Dardevle Brass Back proves that good design is timeless. This spoon has caught more pike over more years than perhaps any other lure in history.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

5. Rapala X-Rap Otus - Innovation Meets Tradition

PREMIUM INNOVATION

Rapala X-Rap Otus XROU-25 Fishing Lure…

8.6
Score ?

25cm body with flexible PVC curl tail

6-point stainless tail locking system

VMC Coastal Black hooks included

Spare tail included for extended use

What We Like
Premium Rapala construction quality
Innovative curl tail design
Spare tail included for value
VMC hooks included
Effective body roll action
What We Don't Like
Higher price point
Limited depth range
May require specific retrieve speeds
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.3★ (119 reviews)
  • Price: $30.29
  • Length: 25cm body
  • Weight: 1.76 oz
  • Running Depth: 0.5-1m
  • Material: ABS body with PVC tail

Rapala took a bold step with the X-Rap Otus, combining a hard body with a soft curl tail. This hybrid approach gives you the casting distance of a hard bait with the seductive action of soft plastic. The 25cm length perfectly mimics the size of prey pike typically target.

The 6-point tail locking system is engineering at its finest. I've fished plenty of hybrid lures where the tail tears off after a few fish, but the Otus tail stays locked in place even after multiple pike attacks. Including a spare tail extends the lure's lifespan significantly - a thoughtful touch considering the price point.

The body roll combined with the curl tail creates a swimming action unlike anything else in my tackle box. The lure tracks straight on the retrieve but has a subtle wobble that suggests an injured baitfish. This triggers strikes from both aggressive and neutral pike.

VMC Coastal Black hooks come standard, and they're sticky sharp right out of the package. These hooks penetrate easily and hold firm during long fights. The black nickel finish resists corrosion better than standard hooks, important when fishing around pike that require steel leaders.

What Customers Love:

  • Premium quality construction throughout
  • Effective curl tail action drives pike wild
  • Spare tail adds significant value

Common Concerns:

  • Price point higher than many alternatives
  • Depth limitations for deeper water

Bottom Line: The Rapala X-Rap Otus represents the premium end of pike lures. If you appreciate innovative design and don't mind paying for quality, this lure delivers unique action that pike haven't seen.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

6. Luhr-Jensen Krocodile - Versatile Distance Caster

DISTANCE CHAMPION

Creek Chub Jointed Pikie Fishing Lure for…

9.2
Score ?

Chrome/Neon Green color combination

Legendary Krocodile spoon design

Heavy-duty construction for abuse

Versatile for multiple species

What We Like
Proven fish-catching design
Excellent casting distance
Durable construction
Works in various water conditions
Great for pike and salmon
What We Don't Like
May twist line without swivel
Paint can chip with use
Single hook option not available
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.6★ (226 reviews)
  • Price: $12.44
  • Weight: 1 oz
  • Color: Chrome/Neon Green
  • Material: Heavy-duty metal

The Krocodile spoon earned legendary status among West Coast salmon anglers before pike fishermen discovered its effectiveness. The unique curved shape creates an erratic action that drives predators crazy. No two retrieves look exactly the same, keeping fish from getting conditioned to the lure's movement.

Casting distance sets the Krocodile apart from other spoons. The weight distribution and aerodynamic shape let me reach spots other anglers can't touch. When pike are spooky in shallow water, being able to cast from 100 feet away makes all the difference.

Luhr-Jensen Krocodile Die 1 Chrome/Neon Green - Customer Photo 1
Customer submitted photo

The Chrome/Neon Green combination excels in various water conditions. The chrome provides flash in clear water while the chartreuse belly gives pike a target in stained conditions. I've caught pike from 3 to 30 feet deep with this single lure.

One trick I learned from a guide in Saskatchewan: add a swivel 18 inches up your line to prevent twist, then work the Krocodile with an erratic retrieve - two quick cranks, pause, one slow crank, repeat. This mimics a wounded baitfish perfectly and triggers strikes from following fish.

What Customers Love:

  • Consistently catches fish in all conditions
  • Great action in water attracts from distance
  • Durable and long-lasting construction
  • Excellent for both pike and salmon

Common Concerns:

  • Line twist issues without swivel
  • Paint durability could be better

Bottom Line: The Luhr-Jensen Krocodile offers exceptional casting distance and proven fish-catching ability. This versatile spoon belongs in every serious pike angler's arsenal.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

7. Dr.Fish Soft Plastic Swimbait - Budget-Friendly Producer

BUDGET PICK

Dr.Fish 3 Pack Musky Spinners, Bucktail...

8.4
Score ?

6 inch soft plastic swimbait design

Realistic swimming action attracts pike

Multiple color options available

Pre-rigged with hooks ready to fish

What We Like
Affordable price point
Realistic swimming action
Good size for pike
Pre-rigged convenience
Multiple colors available
What We Don't Like
Durability concerns with soft plastic
May require replacement after strikes
Limited weight options
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.2★ (85 reviews)
  • Price: $9.99
  • Length: 6 inches
  • Material: Soft Plastic
  • Style: Pre-rigged swimbait

At $9.99, the Dr.Fish Swimbait proves you don't need to spend big money to catch pike. This 6-inch soft plastic perfectly imitates the size of perch and small panfish that make up much of a pike's diet. The pre-rigged design means you can tie it on and start fishing immediately.

The swimming action impressed me more than expected at this price point. The paddle tail thumps steadily on a straight retrieve, but really shines when you add pauses and twitches. Let it sink on slack line and the tail continues to undulate, often triggering strikes from following fish.

Soft plastics have advantages over hard baits in certain situations. Pike can hold onto them longer, giving you extra time to set the hook. They also land quieter in calm water, important when targeting spooky fish in shallow bays. The soft body compresses on the strike, improving hook-up ratios.

The trade-off is durability. Pike teeth will eventually shred any soft plastic, and the Dr.Fish is no exception. Plan on going through several if you're catching fish consistently. At this price, replacing them won't break the bank.

What Customers Love:

  • Good value for money at budget price
  • Catches fish effectively despite low cost
  • Nice swimming action rivals expensive lures

Common Concerns:

  • Durability issues with pike teeth
  • Hook quality could be improved

Bottom Line: The Dr.Fish Swimbait offers solid performance at an unbeatable price. Perfect for beginners or as backup lures when pike are tearing through your tackle.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

8. Heddon Super Spook - Topwater Excitement

TOPWATER MASTER

CREEYA 1piece 3D Duck Topwater Fishing Lure…

9.0
Score ?

Classic walk-the-dog action on surface

Loud rattles for maximum attraction

Proven design for explosive strikes

Durable construction handles pike abuse

What We Like
Exciting topwater strikes
Proven walk-the-dog action
Works in calm conditions
Good casting distance
Durable build quality
What We Don't Like
Requires skill to work properly
Less effective in rough water
May spook fish in clear water
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

Key Specifications:

  • Rating: 4.5★ (312 reviews)
  • Price: $10.99
  • Style: Topwater
  • Action: Walk-the-dog
  • Material: Hard Plastic

Nothing gets your heart racing like a pike exploding on a topwater lure, and the Heddon Super Spook delivers that excitement consistently. This lure has been triggering surface strikes since 1939, and the modern version maintains all the qualities that made it legendary.

The walk-the-dog action takes practice to master, but once you get the rhythm, it's deadly effective. Short, rhythmic twitches make the Spook dart side-to-side while staying in the strike zone longer than straight-retrieving lures. Pike can't resist this wounded, struggling action on the surface.

Heddon Super Spook Topwater Fishing Lure - Customer Photo 1
Customer submitted photo

Timing is everything with topwater fishing. Early morning and late evening produce best, especially when the water is glass calm. I've also had success on overcast days when pike are actively feeding near the surface. The loud rattles call fish from deep water, often resulting in spectacular aerial strikes.

The Super Spook's construction handles pike abuse well. The thick-walled body resists punctures from teeth, and the through-wire construction ensures hooks stay attached during violent strikes. I've landed dozens of pike on a single Spook without significant damage.

What Customers Love:

  • Great topwater action creates excitement
  • Explosive strikes are unforgettable
  • Quality construction lasts season after season
  • Effective for pike in right conditions

Common Concerns:

  • Learning curve for proper action
  • Weather dependent effectiveness

Bottom Line: The Heddon Super Spook brings unmatched excitement to pike fishing. While it won't work in all conditions, when topwater bite is on, nothing beats the visual strikes this lure produces.

View on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you.

How to Choose the Right Pike Lure

Selecting the right pike lure involves understanding several key factors that influence pike behavior and feeding patterns. After two decades of pike fishing across North America, I've learned that success comes from matching your lure choice to specific conditions rather than relying on one "magic" lure.

Water Depth and Structure Considerations

Pike relate to structure differently throughout the year, and your lure needs to reach them effectively. In shallow water (under 6 feet), weedless spoons like the Johnson Silver Minnow and topwater lures excel. These allow you to work over and through vegetation where pike ambush prey.

For mid-depth ranges (6-15 feet), spinnerbaits and swimming plugs give you versatility to cover water columns. The BOOYAH Pikee spinnerbait works particularly well here because you can control depth with retrieve speed. Slow it down to probe deeper or speed up to run shallow.

Deep water pike require heavy spoons and deep-diving crankbaits. The 1-ounce Dardevle and Krocodile spoons sink quickly to reach pike holding near bottom structure. Count them down to the desired depth before starting your retrieve.

Seasonal Lure Selection Strategy

Spring pike are recovering from spawn and often lethargic in cold water. Slow-moving lures with lots of flash work best. The Savage Gear Hybrid Pike with its paddle tail excels when worked slowly over emerging weed beds. Water temperatures between 45-55°F call for deliberate presentations.

Summer brings aggressive pike willing to chase fast-moving lures. This is prime time for inline spinners, buzzbaits, and rapid retrieves with spoons. Pike metabolism peaks in 65-75°F water, making them willing to expend energy chasing prey. The Rapala X-Rap Otus with its unique tail action triggers these active fish.

Fall pike feed heavily to prepare for winter, preferring larger profile lures that represent substantial meals. Oversized soft plastics, magnum spoons, and large swimbaits produce best. The 6-inch Dr.Fish Swimbait matches the size of prey pike target during this feeding frenzy.

Winter pike in open water become sluggish, requiring slow presentations near bottom. Jigging spoons vertically or dead-sticking soft plastics often works better than horizontal presentations. In regions where ice fishing is legal, tip-ups with large minnows under flags remain highly effective.

Color Selection Based on Conditions

Water clarity dictates color choice more than any other factor. In clear water with visibility over 6 feet, natural patterns dominate. Silver, white, and perch patterns blend in enough to not spook wary fish while still attracting attention. The chrome finish on the Krocodile spoon excels in these conditions.

Stained or murky water requires high-contrast colors for visibility. Chartreuse, orange, and white create silhouettes pike can track in low visibility. The Yellow Diamond Dardevle pattern has proven itself in every water clarity, making it a versatile choice when conditions change.

Weather conditions also influence color effectiveness. Bright sunny days call for flash and reflection - chrome, gold, and metallic finishes. Overcast conditions favor solid colors and painted finishes that don't rely on sun for attraction. The BOOYAH Pikee's painted head with flashy blades covers both scenarios.

Size Matters for Pike Lures

Pike are opportunistic and will attack prey up to 1/3 their body length. This means a 30-inch pike won't hesitate to hit a 10-inch lure. However, matching lure size to average pike size in your water increases hook-up ratios. Using oversized lures in waters with mostly small pike results in many follows but few connections.

The 6-7 inch range hits the sweet spot for most pike waters. Lures like the Savage Gear Hybrid Pike at 6.75 inches appeal to both average pike and trophy fish. This size also casts well on standard pike tackle without requiring specialized heavy gear.

When specifically targeting trophy pike over 40 inches, don't be afraid to go big. These fish didn't grow large by expending energy on small meals. The 25cm Rapala X-Rap Otus presents a substantial meal worth their effort.

Understanding types of fishing methods helps you present lures effectively. Casting, trolling, and jigging all have their place in pike fishing, and certain lures excel at specific presentations.

Essential Pike Fishing Techniques

The Figure-8 Technique

Many pike follow lures to the boat without striking. The figure-8 technique converts these followers into caught fish. As your lure approaches the boat, sweep your rod tip in a large figure-8 pattern just below the surface. Keep the lure moving at the same speed as your retrieve. I've caught countless pike within rod-length of the boat using this technique, including several over 40 inches.

Speed Variations and Triggers

Pike often need a trigger to commit to striking. Sudden speed changes, direction shifts, or pauses can flip that switch. With spoons, try a steady retrieve interrupted by sudden rod sweeps that make the spoon dart erratically. For spinnerbaits, killing the retrieve so the lure helicopters down often triggers following fish.

Working Edges and Transitions

Pike are edge hunters. Weed lines, drop-offs, current breaks, and temperature gradients all hold fish. Position your boat to cast parallel to these edges rather than perpendicular. This keeps your lure in the strike zone longer. A spinnerbait or weedless spoon worked right along the weed edge is deadly effective.

Deep Water Tactics

Don't overlook deep water pike, especially during summer. These fish are often less pressured and larger than shallow water pike. Heavy spoons counted down to specific depths let you systematically cover deep structure. Use your electronics to locate baitfish schools and suspended pike, then count your lure down to that exact depth.

Pike Lure Maintenance and Care

Pike are tough on tackle, and proper maintenance extends lure life significantly. After each trip, rinse lures with fresh water to remove algae and debris. Check hooks for sharpness - pike have bony mouths that dull hooks quickly. A few strokes with a hook file keeps them sticky sharp.

Inspect wire components regularly. Spinnerbait wires and through-wire constructions can weaken after multiple fish. Any kinks or bends should be straightened immediately or the lure retired if damage is severe. Split rings also wear and should be replaced periodically.

Store lures properly to prevent damage. Soft plastics should be kept in their original packaging or separated by type to prevent colors from bleeding. Hard baits benefit from individual compartments to prevent hook tangling and finish damage. Never store wet lures in closed containers - this promotes rust and deterioration.

Leaders deserve special attention when pike fishing. Check steel leaders for kinks and fraying after each fish. Even small kinks weaken the leader significantly. Heavy fluorocarbon leaders should be inspected for nicks and abrasions from pike teeth. When in doubt, replace the leader - it's cheap insurance against losing trophy fish.

Safety Considerations When Pike Fishing

Pike demand respect both for their teeth and their power. Long-nose pliers are mandatory for hook removal. Never put your fingers in a pike's mouth - those teeth are designed for holding struggling prey and will shred skin instantly. Jaw spreaders help when hooks are deep, but unhooking on the boat deck is often safer than holding thrashing pike.

Proper handling protects both you and the fish. Support pike horizontally with one hand behind the head and another under the belly. Vertical holds damage internal organs in large fish. For photos, keep the fish over water in case it thrashes free. Quick handling and release improves survival rates, especially in warm water.

Cut hooks when necessary rather than prolonging handling time. Pike are remarkably tough and survive deep hooking better than extended air exposure. Barbless hooks or crimped barbs speed release and reduce damage to both fish and anglers during unhooking.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best all-around pike lure?

The Johnson Silver Minnow spoon stands out as the most versatile pike lure. Its weedless design works in any cover, it casts like a bullet, and at $6.99, you can afford to fish it in the nastiest spots. While specialized lures excel in specific conditions, the Silver Minnow produces consistently in all situations.

What size lure should I use for pike?

For general pike fishing, lures between 5-8 inches work best. This size attracts both average pike and trophy fish without being too large for smaller fish to attack. The Savage Gear Hybrid Pike at 6.75 inches represents an ideal size that won't intimidate 5-pound pike yet still interests 20-pound monsters.

Do I need a steel leader for pike fishing?

Yes, absolutely. Pike teeth will slice through monofilament and fluorocarbon instantly. Use either steel wire or heavy (80-100 lb) fluorocarbon leaders at minimum 12 inches long. The BOOYAH Pikee includes a steel leader, showing how essential they are. I've watched pike bite through 50-pound fluorocarbon like butter.

What colors work best for pike lures?

Bright colors like chartreuse, orange, and white excel in stained water, while natural patterns (silver, perch, pike patterns) work in clear water. The Yellow Diamond pattern on the Dardevle spoon works universally. Red also triggers strikes, possibly because it resembles gills of injured fish.

When is the best time to fish for pike?

Early morning and late evening produce most consistently, especially in summer. Spring and fall offer all-day action as pike feed actively in comfortable water temperatures (55-70°F). Overcast days often produce better than bright sunshine. Peak months vary by region but May-June and September-October are typically excellent.

Should I use treble or single hooks for pike?

Treble hooks provide better hookup ratios, especially important with pike's bony mouths. However, single hooks cause less damage for catch-and-release and are easier to remove. Many anglers replace trebles with inline singles on spoons. The trade-off is worth it if you're releasing fish.

How fast should I retrieve pike lures?

Retrieval speed depends on water temperature and lure type. In cold water (under 50°F), slow retrieves work best. Warmer water allows faster presentations. Spinnerbaits need enough speed to spin blades properly. Vary your retrieve until you find what pike want that day - they'll tell you with strikes.

Can I use bass lures for pike?

Many bass lures work for pike, but you'll need modifications. Add a steel leader, upgrade hooks to handle pike power, and consider upsizing. Large bass spinnerbaits, oversized soft plastics, and magnum crankbaits all catch pike. The Heddon Super Spook works for both species effectively.

Final Thoughts

After testing dozens of pike lures this season, these 8 consistently outperformed the competition. The Savage Gear Hybrid Pike earned our editor's choice for its innovative design and consistent performance across various conditions. At $19.99, it's an investment in serious pike fishing success.

For anglers on a budget, the Johnson Silver Minnow at $6.99 delivers incredible value. This weedless wonder has been catching pike for over a century, and it still outfishes lures costing five times more. Every tackle box needs at least three.

The BOOYAH Pikee Spinnerbait fills the niche for anglers wanting a purpose-built pike spinnerbait. Including the steel leader and using heavy-duty components throughout shows BOOYAH understands what pike anglers need.

Remember that successful pike fishing involves more than just having the right lures. Understanding pike behavior, seasonal patterns, and local forage helps you select and present lures effectively. The best lure is the one you have confidence in and fish properly.

Water conditions change daily, and pike preferences shift with them. Having a selection of lures covering different depths, speeds, and actions ensures you're ready for whatever mood pike are in. Start with these 8 proven producers and expand based on your local waters.

Most importantly, respect these magnificent predators. Practice catch and release when possible, handle fish properly, and follow local regulations. Pike are apex predators that indicate healthy aquatic ecosystems. With proper conservation, future generations will experience the thrill of these explosive strikes.

Whether you're chasing pike through northern wilderness or local reservoirs, these lures give you the tools for success. Tie on a steel leader, pick your weapon from these 8 options, and get ready for arm-wrenching strikes. The water's calling, and somewhere out there, a trophy pike is waiting.

Disclaimer

AquaMarinePower.com does not intend to provide veterinary advice. We go to great lengths to help users better understand their aquatic friends. However, the content on this blog is not a substitute for veterinary guidance. For more information, please read our disclaimer.

Amazon Associates Program

AquaMarinePower.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Copyright © 2023 AMP
cross